On November 16, a research firm put a number on a fear a lot of agency owners already have.
Gartner predicted that by 2030, agency fees will represent 15 percent of marketing budgets, down from 24.5 percent at the start of this decade. That is a forecast, not a promise, and it is about share of the budget, not necessarily the dollars in any one contract.
Even if the exact percentages miss, the direction should make you sit up. The fee line is often the easiest one for a client to shrink without shrinking the work they still want done.
Share of the budget is not the same as your revenue
Gartner named three forces behind the forecast: AI, more work brought in-house, and financial pressure on marketing leaders to spend more efficiently. As companies automate more work and build more capability internally, agency fees become a smaller share of the total.
If your client moves money from the agency line into media, tools, or an internal team, you can still be valued and feel poorer.
The parts of the job that look like scale and throughput are the parts most exposed to a smaller fee. The parts that look like judgment are the parts that have to carry the relationship.
For a $5 million to $25 million firm, this is not an abstract industry chart. A few clients, a few fee structures, and a few pricing habits will decide whether 2027 feels like a repositioning or a haircut.
The hour becomes a trap when the work gets faster
The line I kept coming back to came from Jay Wilson, a VP analyst at Gartner: “Agencies should not be penalized for becoming more productive, and clients should not feel that they are paying primarily for labor that technology has reduced.”
If you still bill mostly by the hour, a faster process can look like a smaller invoice. The client sees less time. You see the same judgment, the same taste, the same accountability, and a tool that cost you money to learn. The old unit of measure starts working against the firm that is actually getting better.
Hours can be an honest way to start a relationship, or to price work you have never done before. They become a problem when they are still the product after the product has changed.
Retainer, project, and the temptation of “value”
Gartner expects more fixed-fee, project-based, and outcome-based pricing, and sees a hybrid as often the most practical structure: a predictable base fee for core strategic services, plus project or performance incentives where the results can be measured reliably.
That sounds clean on a slide. Inside a mid-sized agency, it is messier, and the mess is where the margin lives.
A retainer is a good idea when the client is really buying access to judgment, a named team, and a standing place in the week. It is a fragile idea when it is just a bucket of hours with a monthly label. If the hours get shorter and you cut the retainer to keep the peace, you have just trained them that productivity is a discount. You paid for the tools. They kept the savings.
A project fee is often cleaner, provided the scope is real. If you still build that fee by multiplying estimated hours, you have only changed the wrapper. Price the job, not the production time a tool just compressed.
Outcome-based fees are appealing, and they can be dangerous. Agencies do not control every factor that affects business results. If you attach a meaningful part of your fee to a result the client, the market, or a media platform also drives, you have taken on risk that may not belong on your P&L. Value pricing is not a bonus for a number you cannot steer.
None of this requires you to rip up every contract this week. It does require you to be able to say, in plain language, what the client is buying that a tool cannot. Strategy. Taste. Accountability. A point of view.
Margins, concentration, and the 2027 conversation
I like to see gross margins in the 40 to 50 percent range in a professional service firm. A shift in how clients buy will show up in the margin before it shows up in a press release.
If production gets cheaper and the price stays put, the margin can look better for a while, until the client wants the savings or a competitor offers them. If you pass every efficiency straight through as a lower fee, you funded the new way of working and kept none of the benefit. The worst version is not choosing, and finding out later that the fee moved without you.
Concentration makes that weaker. I do not like to see one client above 20 to 25 percent of revenue, and that matters more when the industry fee line is under pressure. A client who is a third of your book does not need a research note to ask for a smaller share of their budget. They already have the leverage.
AI belongs in this conversation as a cost and as a change in the work, not as a slogan. If you cannot explain what the human is still doing, the fee is the line that gets cut. If you can, you have a 2027 pricing conversation about the work, not about defending last year’s hours.
Look at your revenue the way a client is about to look at their budget. How much is a retainer that is really a pile of hours, a project fee built from those same hours, or a fee tied to an outcome you do not control? Then notice which of the work inside those fees has already gotten faster, and which of it is still the reason they hired you.
You do not need a new manifesto. You need a point of view before the next renewal or the next “can we rethink the model?” email. Some relationships should move to a clearer fee. Some should stay as they are, on purpose. The mistake is letting the model drift while the tools change.
Clients are not wrong to ask what they are paying for. The next few years will sort out the people who can answer that in plain language from the people who hope the old rate card holds.
If time is no longer the product, the product has to be named.
Want Monday Morning Business Tips in your inbox first? Sign up at the bottom of finstratcfo.com.
Thanks for reading FinStrat CFO! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Originally published on Substack.
Comments