“Oh my god, he’s gonna quit, let’s give him $10,000.”
Those were actual calls I used to get from CEOs and senior leaders.
A key employee was about to resign, and instead of looking at the numbers, emotions took over. No model. No P&L. No look at what that number actually costs over three years.
Just fear and panic.
I get it. I’ve been on the other side of that panic. A key person hints they might leave, and suddenly you’re not thinking like a CFO. You’re thinking like someone standing in a doorway trying to keep it from closing.
Why the panic shows up so fast
A resignation never arrives at a convenient time. There’s work in flight, clients who like this person, and a week that already looked tight. If you run an agency or a professional services firm, that tightness may not be an accident. I’ve watched the same cycle at firm after firm: over-hire in the good years, consolidate in the lean years, and come out the other side understaffed but “high margin.” Then repeat.
So when a key person talks about leaving, it doesn’t feel like a compensation question. It feels like the floor moving. You reach for the fastest fix, and the number that comes out of your mouth is a round one, invented in the time it takes to say it.
One CEO was honest enough to name the habit outright: “It’s always been a little bit more instinct-based versus data-driven.” Instinct isn’t the enemy. Instinct without numbers is.
$10,000 is not a $10,000 decision
If that $10,000 goes into base pay, it isn’t a one-time check. It’s a raise, and it shows up every year after that.
→ Year one: $10,000
→ Year two: $10,000
→ Year three: $10,000
That’s $30,000 over three years, before anyone talks about the next increase. Then add the employer’s share of payroll taxes (up to another $765 a year), plus any benefits and retirement match that move with salary. The $10,000 is the starting number, not the ending one.
And that’s only the person you’re trying to keep.
The cost that doesn’t show up in the offer
Pay $10,000 because someone was about to leave, and you’ve put a price on threatening to walk, whether you meant to or not. The people who didn’t threaten anything will notice. Some will ask. Some won’t, and that can be worse.
You may also be buying less than you think. A counteroffer can keep someone this quarter. It doesn’t fix why they were leaving. If the problem was the work, the manager, or the hours, the $10,000 doesn’t touch it. You’ve bought time. That’s useful. It isn’t a solution.
Four questions before you say yes
Before any hire, I ask CEOs four things. They work just as well for a raise you didn’t plan.
What’s our actual capacity versus demand right now?
If you can’t answer that, the panic is doing the math for you. Sometimes the work can be covered, and the real emergency is that you never measured whether you could.
Is this a role gap, or a person gap?
Are you trying to keep this function, or this human? Ask them, plainly, what would actually make them stay. You may not like the answer. Hear it before you attach a raise to it.
What does this cost over three years?
Run the raise out three years, add the taxes and benefits, and ask whether cash and margin can absorb it without shortchanging the next hire you actually need.
Are we solving today’s fire, or building for tomorrow’s growth?
If you underpaid someone and you’re late, a planned adjustment is the honest fix. That’s different from a hostage payment, which teaches everyone that the way to get a raise is to resign a little.
Get out of the doorway
Slow the decision down. Most resignations can survive a night of thinking, and a night is long enough to put the three-year cost on a page. If you can’t afford it, saying no is a business decision, not a character flaw.
Then stop saving compensation conversations for the day someone resigns. Put pay on a calendar. Reviews, raises, and bonuses should happen on purpose, in a season you chose, with a look at cash, not in a doorway in the middle of a client deadline.
And know what each role is worth to the firm before the call ever happens. A range you can defend, based on the work, the margin, and what you can afford. If you only figure that out when someone has an offer in hand, you’re late. That’s how $10,000 gets invented in a sentence.
If you want a second set of eyes on a compensation decision before you make it in a hallway, send me a DM or an email at joehamrahi@finstratcfo.com.
Want Monday Morning Business Tips in your inbox first? Sign up at the bottom of finstratcfo.com.
Thanks for reading FinStrat CFO! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Originally published on Substack.
Comments