
Every one of us has done this at a restaurant.
The server comes over. You’ve had the menu for ten minutes. You look up and say, “What do you recommend?”
That’s a perfectly good question. The server knows the kitchen. They know the short rib is great tonight and the fish is a little tired. You take the advice, and then you order. You own the order. If the short rib disappoints, you don’t ask to speak to the manager about the server’s judgment.
Now picture the same question in an office.
A founder has been sitting on a decision for six weeks. Hire or don’t hire. Keep the client or let them go. Raise prices or wait another quarter. The team has done the work. The numbers are on the table. And the founder looks up and says, “What do you recommend?”
Then says it again next week. To a different person.
The email that moves the blame
I’ve spent 35 years in finance, 25 of them as a CFO. I’ve sat in a lot of rooms where a decision needed to be made.
And I’ll say what I’ve been noticing: I see this far more often lately than I ever did.
Leaders, including experienced ones who have run companies through real storms, who can’t make a call. They ask for a recommendation. Then a second opinion. Then a meeting about the memo.
Sometimes it’s honest uncertainty. But a lot of the time, the request for a recommendation isn’t really about advice. It’s about paperwork.
If the call goes well, the leader made a great decision. If it goes badly, well, that’s what the CFO recommended. There’s an email with someone else’s name on it, and that email is a very comfortable place to stand.
I say this with affection: that’s not asking for input. That’s buying insurance and charging the premium to your team.
Consensus is a nice place to hide
The more sophisticated version doesn’t look like avoidance at all. It looks like collaboration.
“Let’s get everyone’s input.” “Let’s take it back to the group.”
Input is good. But there’s a difference between gathering views so you can decide and gathering views so you never have to.
You can tell which one is happening by what comes next. A leader who wants input listens, thanks people, and makes the call. A leader who is hiding asks for one more round. When everyone decided, nobody decided, and nobody can be blamed.
The team notices. They always notice.
Decision debt is still debt
Finance people think about debt all day, so here’s how I think about this.
Every decision you push off doesn’t go away. It goes on a tab. And like any tab, it runs up interest.
→ The opportunity doesn’t wait. The client signs with someone else. The great candidate takes the other offer.
→ Your team slows down. Everything downstream sits in a holding pattern.
→ Your best people get frustrated first. If every call stalls on your desk, they’ll go find a desk where things move.
→ The decision gets made anyway. By the market, a competitor or a cash crunch. Just later, with worse terms.
None of that shows up on the P&L as “indecision.” It shows up as slower growth and turnover everyone blames on something else.
Why it seems to be happening more
I don’t have a study for this. I have a lot of years in a lot of rooms. Here’s my read.
There’s more uncertainty and more information. When the ground feels like it’s moving, standing still feels responsible. And there’s always one more report, one more dashboard, one more AI tool happy to give you twelve options. More data can become a very respectable way to never finish.
Blame travels faster. A bad call used to be a private lesson. Now it can be a Slack thread or a public post. When people are afraid of being the name attached to a mistake, they start collecting other names.
And sometimes it’s just fear. Fear of being wrong, or of being found out. Experience doesn’t make it disappear. Sometimes it makes it worse, because now there’s a reputation to protect.
Careful or avoiding?
To be fair, not every slow decision is avoidance. Some decisions are big, expensive and hard to undo. Jeff Bezos famously called those one-way doors, and they deserve time. Most decisions are two-way doors. If you get one wrong, you walk back through.
A careful leader slows down on the one-way doors and moves quickly on the rest. An avoiding leader treats every door like it’s bolted shut.
A careful leader asks for a recommendation and then owns the outcome. An avoiding leader asks for one so they don’t have to.
Five questions before you pass the potato
The next time you catch yourself typing “What do you recommend?” try these first. Five minutes, honest answers.
-
Is this a one-way door or a two-way door? If you can undo it in a month without real damage, you’ve probably already spent too long on it.
-
What would I decide if I had to decide today? You almost always know. Write it down before you ask anyone else.
-
What specific information would change my mind? If you can name it, go get it, with a deadline. If you can’t name it, you’re not missing information. You’re missing nerve.
-
Why am I asking for a recommendation? To get better thinking, or to have a name to point to later? Be honest. Nobody else is reading this.
-
Who is waiting on this? Put a name and a cost next to the delay. Your team, a client, a candidate. The tab is running whether you look at it or not.
And when you do decide, say it plainly. “I’ve heard everyone. Here’s the call. It’s mine.” Those last two words do more for a team than any recommendation memo ever written.
Order something
Going back to that restaurant for a second.
Asking the server what they recommend is smart. Asking them, then asking the table, then asking the next table over, then sending the server back to check with the chef, while everyone else’s food gets cold, is something else.
At some point, you have to order.
Your team doesn’t need you to be right every time. They need you to decide, own it, and adjust when you learn something. That’s the whole job.
Want Monday Morning Business Tips in your inbox first? Sign up at the bottom of finstratcfo.com.
Thanks for reading FinStrat CFO! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Originally published on Substack.
Comments