FinStrat CFO
FinStrat CFO
Fractional CFO Exit & M&A AI for Finance Coaching Speaking The Book Blog About
Book a call
fFractional CFO
eExit & M&A
aAI for Finance
cCoaching
sSpeaking
tThe Book
Blog
aAbout
Book a call
Back

Every Business Has a Transfer Portal

Joe Hamrahi·Nov 3, 2026· 7 minutes

Every Business Has a Transfer Portal

There’s a particular kind of quiet in a house on a fall Saturday morning.

The coffee’s on. The pregame show is already arguing about something. Somebody is wearing a jersey they’ve owned since before their kids were born. By noon, the group text is a mix of trash talk, injury rumors and a photo of someone’s chili.

College football is a ritual. It’s tailgates, fight songs, rivalry week and an unshakable belief that this is finally our year.

It’s also, since the summer of 2025, officially a business with a payroll.

I say that with affection. I’ve spent 35 years in finance, and I have never seen a sport put its balance sheet on the front page quite like this.

The day the roster became a budget

In June 2025, a federal judge approved the House v. NCAA settlement. Starting July 1, 2025, schools that opted in could pay their athletes directly.

There’s a cap on it, too. For this school year, each participating school can share up to $21.58 million with its athletes, according to the College Sports Commission, the new body that oversees the system. On top of that, players can still earn money from outside name, image and likeness deals.

Scholarship limits went away at the schools that opted in. Roster limits came in. A football roster now tops out at 105.

And a lot of programs did what any company does when payroll gets serious. They hired general managers. Some brought in people straight from NFL front offices to run the cap, the contracts and the roster.

Read that list again: a payroll cap, a roster limit, a GM, contracts.

That’s not a team. That’s a company with a marching band.

The portal is just a job market with better lighting

Then there’s the transfer portal.

Every January, there’s a window when players can declare they want to move. Coaches who spent the fall building a depth chart wake up to find a chunk of it in the portal, and on every recruiting site by lunch. Fans refresh their phones like it’s election night.

The NCAA just shortened that window. For this coming cycle, football players get 10 days, January 4 through January 13.

Ten days to lose your starting left tackle.

Here’s the part I want every founder to sit with. The portal didn’t create the desire to leave. It just gave that desire a calendar and a public list.

Your business doesn’t have a portal with a window. Your people can leave any week of the year. They just don’t announce it on television.

They update a LinkedIn profile. They take a recruiter’s call during lunch. They start leaving at 5:01. And one Monday you get the “do you have a few minutes?” message, and the depth chart you thought you had turns out to be a rumor.

Retention is a finance line, not a feeling

In most small companies, retention lives in the “soft stuff” pile. Culture. Vibes. Pizza Fridays.

College athletic departments don’t have that luxury anymore. When a player leaves, they can see exactly what walked out the door: the money already invested, the snaps they’ll now give to someone less ready, and the cost of finding a replacement in a crowded market.

Your business has the same math. It’s just hidden in different places.

When a good person leaves, you pay for it in recruiting time, in the months it takes someone new to get fully up to speed, in the client who notices the change and starts asking questions, and in the overtime everyone else quietly absorbs.

None of that shows up on a line called “turnover.” It hides in margin. It hides in your calendar. It hides in the client renewal that came in a little softer than it should have.

That’s why I treat retention as a finance question. Not because people are numbers. Because losing them has a cost, and costs you don’t measure have a way of getting bigger.

Don’t pay the quarterback and starve the line

Every fall, there’s some version of the same story. A program spends big on one star, the highlight reel looks incredible, and then the offensive line can’t keep anyone upright through November.

Businesses do this all the time.

One rainmaker gets paid like a franchise player. Meanwhile the people actually doing the work are underpaid, overloaded and one recruiter call away from the portal. It works right up until it doesn’t.

A cap forces a question most founders avoid: if I only have so much to spend on people, where does each dollar do the most?

Sometimes the answer is the star. Often it’s the depth chart. The project manager who keeps three clients calm. The analyst nobody outside the building has heard of. The person who answers the phone when things break.

Stars win games. Depth wins seasons.

Ranking season is coming for you too

The first College Football Playoff rankings drop Tuesday night. For the next several weeks, every fan base will argue about where their team really stands.

Late season is when the truth comes out. Injuries pile up. The schedule gets harder. The teams with real depth start pulling away from the teams that only had a great September.

Business has a late season too. It’s right now. Budgets for next year. Raises. Bonuses. Year-end reviews. And in a lot of industries, January is when people decide whether to stay.

Which means the time to look at your roster is before your portal opens, not after.

The roster check

So here’s my halftime adjustment for founders. Five questions, about fifteen minutes, and an honest face.

  1. Who would hurt the most to lose in January? Write down three names. If you can’t, you don’t know your roster. If you can, ask yourself when you last told them they matter.

  2. What would it actually cost to replace each of them? Recruiting time, ramp-up months, client risk and the overtime everyone else would absorb. You don’t need precision. You need to stop pretending the number is zero.

  3. Is your people budget built on purpose or by accident? Look at it the way a GM looks at the cap. Are you paying for what matters most, or for whoever negotiated hardest?

  4. Are you overpaying one star and starving the depth chart? If one person left and the whole operation wobbled, that’s not a star. That’s a single point of failure with a nice title.

  5. Who’s quietly checking the portal right now? You probably have a guess. Have the conversation before they do.

Your payroll isn’t an expense line. It’s your roster. Budget it like you want to win in November.

See you in the stands

I love that college football still feels like a Saturday ritual, even with GMs and payroll caps. The fight songs didn’t change. The tailgates still exist. What changed is that the business underneath is finally out in the open.

Yours is too. It always was.

So which player on your roster would you hate to see in the portal this January? And do they know it?

Want Monday Morning Business Tips in your inbox first? Sign up at the bottom of finstratcfo.com.

Thanks for reading FinStrat CFO! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Subscribe on Substack

Originally published on Substack.

Newer post Your Org Chart Is a Peace Treaty
Older post Show Them the Numbers

Comments

Please log in or register to post a comment
FinStrat CFO
FinStrat CFO

Fractional CFO for professional service firms.

Services
Fractional CFO Exit Readiness & M&A AI for Finance Coaching & Education Speaking
Company
About The book Blog Substack Contact
Connect
LinkedIn Email Joe Ask CFJoe
Copyright © 2026 FinStrat CFO